What was the same in the two roofing quotes?
The roofer supplied $377,054 in annual revenue, $133,183 in subcontracted labor and no W-2 employees. The submitted roofing mix was 99% residential and 1% commercial. Both saved general liability indications used that application and showed $1 million each occurrence and $2 million general aggregate limits. Neither indication was bound.
The claims-made indication showed $1,359.42 per year; the occurrence indication showed $1,795.09 per year. This is one business with two saved documents, not a survey of what roofers usually pay. Keeping the same exposure figures lets us focus on the policy-form difference without pretending the policies are otherwise identical.
- Match the named insured, work mix, policy period, receipts and loss history.
- Keep subcontractor costs separate from W-2 payroll, even when payroll is zero.
- Record the stated limits and policy form next to each quoted annual price.
Why the lower annual price may not answer the contract
Claims-made and occurrence liability forms respond using different timing rules. The customer's contract may ask for an occurrence policy, completed-operations terms, additional-insured wording or a specified duration of protection. A cheaper number cannot answer those terms by itself.
Give the broker the customer's insurance exhibit and ask them to compare the actual proposed forms and endorsements. If a quote does not match a requirement, ask whether a different proposal or change is available before using that price in a bid. A certificate is evidence of a policy; it does not amend the policy or create an endorsement.
- Ask whether the customer contract requires occurrence coverage.
- Compare completed-operations and additional-insured wording in the proposed documents.
- Resolve any gap with the reviewer before telling a GC the insurance requirement is met.
Compare the roof work each proposal actually accepts
The label roofing contractor is not enough to compare proposals. List residential and commercial shares, repairs versus replacements, steep and low-slope systems, maximum heights, tear-offs, hot work, open-roof exposure and the tasks subcontractors perform. Ask the reviewer to identify any restrictions that matter to those jobs.
If the next contract adds a roof system or method missing from the application, have both quotes reviewed on that same revised scope. Otherwise the price difference mixes policy terms with different work descriptions.
- Describe the largest and occasional jobs, not just routine shingle work.
- Give each reviewer the same subcontracted tasks and costs.
- Check proposed exclusions and endorsements against the actual bid.
A simple way to compare your own roofing proposals
Put each proposal in one column: annual premium and total payment terms; policy period and form; limits; accepted roof operations; subcontractor rating basis; deductibles; and the customer's contract requirements. Mark missing information as unknown and request the document or correction. Do not fill a blank from another insurer's proposal.
The $1,359.42 and $1,795.09 figures are historical quotes for this roofer, not current offers or an average. Send your own work and business figures to request a current comparison.
Your quote comparison checklist
Mark completed tasks, then download a copy with room for owners, dates, and notes. Progress stays on this page until you leave or refresh. No email required.
0 of 9 completed
Use this guide for planning. Confirm requirements and current fees with the agencies serving your address. Coverage depends on the policy and insurer; this guide does not confirm that a particular operation is eligible.